VIDEO ESSAY · ALL ARTICLES

Why Ancient Greek Pyrrhonism Is Buddhism — Arhat Live Broadcast

READ · QUESTION · VERIFY

A Late Start and the Fragility of the Democratic System

Today’s broadcast began later than usual. I normally prepare in advance before going live, but today I was distracted by matters at home. I had not even put up the scheduled broadcast screen, so some people may have left thinking there would be no broadcast. I first apologized to everyone who had waited. One reason I could not begin until nearly 8:20 was that I had to prepare my mother’s meal. My younger brother was away, and since it was just my mother and me at home, I had no choice but to look after it.

Before beginning the broadcast in earnest, I also addressed the political situation unfolding at the time. It was bewildering that Yoon Suk Yeol had suddenly been released from detention and was out. The entire nation had directly witnessed the conduct of a sitting president who made decisions in his own way without proper deliberation and tried to manipulate the country as he pleased through martial law. I called him a major criminal. The fact that such a person was suddenly released showed, in my view, that our country still had not built an adequate system worthy of a proper democracy.

People imagine that democracy and the machinery of the state are solemn and firmly constructed. Yet institutions differ from one country to another, and the histories of the modern state and democracy are not very long. It has not been long since societies once ruled by monarchs and nobles gave sovereignty to the people and created a system in which a person entrusted with authority by public agreement governs temporarily. It is therefore full of holes and problems. In the past, Korea looked at foreign modern states and copied their constitutions and principles. If one asks whom the Republic of Korea should copy now, I want to answer that this is no longer a time to follow others. It is time for us to lead.

Are the institutions of the United States, Britain, and France perfect? I doubt it. Our people must now move into territory no other country has explored. We must create a democratic state in which the people exercise sovereignty more soundly, and we must repair a system so fragile that prosecutors can release a person accused of crimes against the public will merely because he is president, concocting an absurd justification, while no one can immediately hold them responsible. I even said crudely that they act this way because they treat the people like dirt. In that respect, I believe an adequate and unequivocal punishment is necessary.

There is also a comic side to broadcasting live from home. For an hour, my wife, my elementary-school-aged son, my mother, and my younger siblings all have to stop what they are doing and remain quiet. At home I become something of a tyrant, forcing silence on everyone. After asking my mother several times, “Please be quiet just a little longer. The broadcast is starting,” and boiling water for a cup of coffee, I began taking questions.

Why Ancient Greek Pyrrhonism Is Buddhism

In recent live broadcasts, I have often said that Western modernity is deeply connected with Buddhism and that the modern West arose under its influence. As one catalyst, I pointed to the Epicurean work De rerum natura, a book about the nature of things rediscovered in the West in 1417. This book strongly influenced the Renaissance and the Scientific Revolution. The Epicurean school took shape after 300 BCE and wielded considerable influence alongside the Stoic school during the Roman era. Around 400 CE, however, Christianity became dominant, and philosophies such as Stoicism, Epicureanism, and Pyrrhonism began to disappear. They were rediscovered with the Renaissance in the early fifteenth century. I find the intellectual roots that produced today’s nation-state in this current as well.

The figure I wanted to examine within that current was Pyrrho of Elis. In the early 300s BCE, he followed Alexander the Great in the war between the Greek coalition and the Persian Empire. At that time, the Persian Empire was enormous, reaching from Greek lands in the west to northwestern India, the Indus basin, and Gandhara in the east. A broad network of exchange already existed around 500 BCE, close to the period in which the Buddha lived. By the time Alexander’s army reached northwestern India at the eastern end of Persia, Buddhism had already spread to that region. I believe Pyrrho learned Buddhism there, particularly at Taxila, and then returned to Greece.

After returning, Pyrrho left behind the philosophy of Pyrrhonism. That is why I call him “a Buddhist practitioner of the Greek West.” Yet people who practice Buddhism fail to recognize why Pyrrho’s teaching is Buddhist, while scholars of Pyrrhonism fail to appreciate its resemblance to Buddhism. This is because such a broad range of religious elements entered Buddhism and blurred its original identity. Someone has even written a book on the resemblance between Pyrrho and Buddhism, but it is not widely known. I therefore set out to compare specific terms and concepts and show why Pyrrho’s teaching is Buddhism.

Does a Dog Have Buddha-Nature?

Before I entered the main subject, a viewer asked, “Do people and dogs have Buddha-nature or not? What in the world is Buddha-nature?” It is usually explained as the quality that enables one to become a Buddha, a capacity for awakening. I return a question: Did the Buddha himself actually speak of Buddha-nature? Did he say that such a thing existed? Anyone who considers the character of Buddhism as I have explained it can make a reasonable guess.

As a rule, the Buddha does not create a new concept and establish that “such a thing exists.” He dismantles even existing concepts. Dharma does not mean only the rules we must observe. The human linguistic concepts used when we say that something is born, dies, increases, decreases, brings joy, or brings sadness are all dharmas. They are signs and images, standards, language, and concepts. The “signs” in the Diamond Sutra phrase “to see all signs as non-signs is to see the Tathagata” point to the same problem. Their displayed characteristics differ slightly, but all these dharmas made and named by humans lack own-nature.

Would Buddhism then suddenly create a new concept and assert that a thing called Buddha-nature exists? Jainism says that there is jiva, a soul that does not die when the body dies and continues through rebirth, and that there is ajiva, the material that is not jiva. It establishes components such as time and space, body and mind, as things that truly exist. Buddhism, however, does not establish new substances of that kind. The Chinese term “Buddha-nature” itself asks whether the quality of a Buddha exists. In my view, a term like this could arise only later, after Buddhism had lost much of its original meaning.

The problem remains even if “everyone has Buddha-nature” is changed to “everyone can become a Buddha.” Can an eighty- or ninety-year-old person with dementia become a Buddha now? What about a one-year-old infant? Can a cicada clinging to a tree and chirping become a Buddha? Before that, we must ask what a Buddha is. The definition differs from person to person. Some may think a Buddha is a being who uses supernatural powers, sees past lives, and flies, but that is not the Buddha I mean. Arguing about which beings do or do not possess Buddha-nature when we cannot even agree on what a Buddha is amounts to metaphysics barking up the wrong tree. Rather than rashly defining Buddha-nature in response to “What is it?” I ask back, “What exactly is this Buddha-nature you are talking about?”

Adiaphora and Wisdom Free of Discrimination

To explain Pyrrhonism, I opened the English Wikipedia article on “adiaphora.” The Korean page bearing the same title is extremely short, while the English page is far longer. Although I can read English, doing so takes four or five times longer than reading Korean, so I use the Chrome browser’s artificial-intelligence translation to render English documents into Korean. Now that translation tools have improved, I recommended that people not remain confined to sparse Korean pages but consult English Wikipedia as well.

Adiaphora is also a term used in Christianity. Later Christianity understands it as something intermediate that is neither good nor evil. I regard that as an interpretation that has lost the original meaning. The prefix “a-” means not, no, or otherwise, a negation similar to “mu” in the Buddhist term no-self. “Diaphora” means difference, distinction, or division and can be connected to the English word difference. Thus, if diaphora is discriminating wisdom that establishes differences and divides, adiaphora is non-discriminating wisdom that does not establish those divisions.

Diaphora sees things by dividing them into arising and ceasing, dirty and clean, good and evil, increasing and decreasing. Adiaphora, by contrast, corresponds to neither arising nor ceasing, which denies that arising and ceasing exist separately; neither defiled nor pure, which denies the division between dirty and clean; and neither increasing nor decreasing, which denies the division between gain and loss. I explained this as the Heart Sutra’s teaching that the characteristics of all dharmas are emptiness. It does not establish some separate middle thing that is “neither this nor that.” It releases the very discrimination that divides this and that into fixed, real differences.

Part of this skeptical current also existed among Sophists and in Socrates before Pyrrho. Socrates said, “I neither know nor think that I know.” This attitude, which asks about knowing and not knowing, belongs to someone who seeks wisdom. The word sophist originally referred to a wise person, a seeker of wisdom. I said that completely separating Socrates from the Sophists and learning that Sophists were merely makers of specious arguments was also wrong. Socrates questioned the inherited gods and moral ideas, and he was put to death on charges that he denied the gods and taught the young to destroy established morality.

Around 500 BCE, various sramanas and brahmins in India, the Hundred Schools of Thought in China, and Sophists and philosophers in Greece all began asking questions. Western accounts sometimes say such intellectual awakenings occurred independently and without connection in different parts of the world. I find that implausible. Eurasia possessed a powerful network, and China, India, Persia, Egypt, and Greece continually exchanged people and ideas. The Buddha, too, emerged through the conditions of this human network.

I also mentioned Diogenes and the Cynic school. Diogenes was a practitioner who did not pursue property and lived by begging. He resembled a naked ascetic or a Buddhist bhikkhu living on alms. The Stoic and Epicurean schools, influenced by Pyrrhonism, likewise spoke of adiaphora, but later generations misunderstood it as a morally neutral realm that was neither good nor evil. When people forget what the originator meant, a concept degenerates in this way. I strongly criticized Christian disputes over adiaphora as misguided debates by later people who no longer understood the original meaning.

Rejecting Dogma and Suspending Judgment

The first sentence I encountered upon opening the article on Pyrrhonism was, “Pyrrhonism rejects dogma.” One must understand this sentence. In Buddhist terms, dogma is dharma. Statements that the world consists of certain components, that a soul exists, that karma and rebirth exist, or that this is right and that is wrong are all language and concepts—all dharmas. Buddhism does not create such new dharmas and have us grasp them as real substances. It therefore has no reason to establish Buddha-nature as a new substance.

Jainism establishes jiva and ajiva, karma, soul, and rebirth, and it explains that one escapes rebirth by cleansing the impurity attached to the soul and becoming pure. The Buddhism I mean, however, does not assume that a mental entity can exist separately from body and matter. It negates to the end the dharmas—that is, the signs, views, standards, and dogmas—that humans fashion through sensation, perception, imagination, and linguistic concepts for convenience. Pyrrhonism’s rejection of dogma from the outset means that it does not claim that some substance exists. I can smell Buddhism in that very first sentence.

Pyrrho learned Buddhism at Taxila, returned, and argued that judgment should be suspended. Suspending or withholding judgment corresponds to the Buddhist practice of “stopping.” In the practice of stopping and observing, the first is to stop and the second is to observe. The paired cultivation of concentration and wisdom and the joint practice of stopping and observation point to these two directions: stop and observe. I explained that one function of meditative concentration is to help a person experience the suspension of judgment in actual life. Pyrrho himself lived by making every effort to enter such a tranquil state.

Today, however, people hear the name “skepticism” and consider it bad. I especially criticized the Buddhist Samannaphala Sutta as “a foolish scripture” and “a scripture made later.” It denigrates the skepticism and materialism of other sramanas while establishing its own claims about karma, rebirth, merit, supernatural powers, and seeing past lives. It must reject skepticism and materialism in order to declare that rebirth exists and that good deeds produce merit. Buddhism, however, tells us not to cling even to the dharmas of good and evil and to break human-made concepts to the very end. If one invents strange concepts and then insists that people must observe precepts, acquire merit, cultivate karma, and escape rebirth, that is what is actually non-Buddhist.

I therefore went so far as to say that the Samannaphala Sutta is not a Buddhist scripture. Nor did I conceal my harsh judgment that eighty to ninety percent of Buddhist scriptures are at a level one can scarcely call Buddhist. By contrast, the genuine taste of Buddhism remains alive in Pyrrhonism. The fact that the Epicurean and Stoic schools influenced by Pyrrho became central to Western philosophy also belongs to this current.

The Pyrrhonist pursuit of ataraxia is another example. “A-” is a negation, and the rest refers to being disturbed, so ataraxia is an undisturbed state, an unshakable mind. It is the peaceful and tranquil condition that comes when judgment is suspended. I correlated it with the stillness of nirvana. Stillness means quiet and tranquility, while nirvana is the extinguishing of a fire. When judgment stops, the fire of thought goes out. Pyrrhonist ataraxia is therefore no different from the stillness of nirvana as I understand it.

Pyrrho’s Three Questions and the Emptiness of Dharmas

Pyrrhonism asks about the path to happiness, or eudaimonia. This pursuit of happiness later continued in the Epicurean school and is commonly misunderstood through the negatively colored label “hedonism.” I called it a philosophy of happiness. I connected this current even to the right to pursue happiness in Article 10 of the Constitution of the Republic of Korea. Since Pyrrho’s eudaimonia came from Buddhism, I joked with some exaggeration that “Article 10 of the Korean Constitution is Buddhism’s fault.”

In describing the person who reaches happiness, Pyrrho posed three questions. What is the nature of pragmata—ethical problems, matters, and dharmas? What attitude should we take toward them? What result follows for the person who has such an attitude? I explained that pragmata likewise denotes every dharma conceptualized as something one must follow or reject, something right or wrong.

First, dharmas are adiaphora. They cannot be fixed and distinguished through logical differences. Arising and ceasing are not separate substances, nor do defilement and purity possess separate own-natures. Second, they are astathmeta: unstable, unbalanced, and immeasurable, which calls impermanence and no-self to mind. Third, they are anepikrita: unjudged, indeterminate, and undecidable. This resembles the reason Buddhism repeatedly uses words that negate existing reifications—no-self, impermanence, neither arising nor ceasing, neither defiled nor pure, neither increasing nor decreasing—rather than erecting new positive nouns.

Our sensory perceptions and doxai—our views, theories, and beliefs—do not state truth or falsehood itself. Neither the world seen through our five senses nor the concepts in our heads declaring “this is such and that is otherwise” can clearly establish whether something is true or false. We therefore must not depend on them to reach fixed judgments. The Pyrrhonist is adoxastoi, holding no view, and aklineis, inclining to neither side. This is the middle way. The middle way is not the arithmetical midpoint between two extremes.

The Pyrrhonist is also akradantoi, refusing a choice and remaining unwavering. Skeptical formulations say of everything that it is neither existent nor nonexistent, both existent and nonexistent, and neither existent nor nonexistent. To someone who has not reflected deeply, these words sound like sophistry. That is why Sophists and skeptics are called makers of specious arguments. With deeper thought, however, one sees that they connect with the claim that dharmas are empty and lack own-nature and that all things arise dependently, are impermanent, and have no self.

Even the words “arises” and “disappears” are fragmentary language, views, and dharmas. The world’s character is not confined within those words. Thinking in terms of dependent arising enables us to see that the words and discriminations we grasp are not reality itself. I therefore call Pyrrhonism Buddhism because it speaks of the emptiness of dharmas, the emptiness of own-nature, dependent arising, impermanence, and no-self. If one cannot feel Buddhism in these words, it is because one does not understand Buddhism; if a scholar of Pyrrhonism seeks its source only within Greece, it is because that scholar does not know its Buddhist connection.

How Skepticism Led to Modernity and Democracy

The ideas of Pyrrho, Epicurus, and the Stoics disappeared in the Middle Ages and revived during the Renaissance. Montaigne received that current and wrote works that tested and questioned in the form of the essai. I also noted that Montaigne died around the time of the Japanese invasions of Korea. Skepticism and materialism then influenced Francis Bacon, empiricism, the Scientific Revolution, and the fundamental spirit that built modern society.

Why should the power of kings and nobles pass through blood? Does a real distinction make aristocratic blood clean and common blood dirty? Is anyone born a king? Does a god truly exist? Only skepticism that asks these questions can doubt authority and status. The power to turn back toward what I believe I know and think critically leads to science, the nation-state, and democracy. I believe that fundamental spirit came from Buddhist skepticism, thinking through dependent arising, and the practice of asking questions.

To escape my delusions, I must observe and ask questions. One cannot become a Buddha without questioning oneself. Do not become subordinate or bound to any dharma.

This is why I traced Pyrrhonism all the way to today’s constitution and democracy. If Buddhism is not turned into a list of transcendent beliefs but understood as a life of doubting the dharmas I grasp, suspending judgment, and observing again, Pyrrho’s words no longer sound like an alien Western philosophy. They sound like familiar Buddhist language.

A Question About Suicide: The Individual Mind and Social Structure

After I finished the main explanation, a viewer asked, “Did the Buddha ever teach about suicide? From the perspectives of the impermanence of all formations, the no-self of all dharmas, the Four Noble Truths, and the Noble Eightfold Path that removes suffering, how should we view the suicide of people in pain?” I first answered honestly that I did not know. I do not know what the Buddha actually said about suicide, or even whether he said anything about it. If someone says, “The Buddha said this,” one should not believe it immediately but ask whether it truly was the Buddha’s statement.

I had, however, spoken recently about people who despair of life. It is not only those who were poor and powerless from the beginning who die by suicide. People who achieved social success and then lost it, as well as those who were born wealthy and prospered before losing something, also take their own lives. Others, of course, think of death because life is too hard or reality differs too sharply from what they imagined. In the end, when one despairs of life and the world does not proceed according to one’s wishes, a thought such as “Should I just die?” arises.

From a Buddhist perspective, one must first ask where this “my will” and its standards came from. Is that standard right? Must the world naturally unfold according to my wishes? A suffering person often feels that everyone else lives as they desire and that it is unjust and miserable that only their own life does not. Yet no one in this world accomplishes everything and lives exactly as they please. When trapped inside one’s own thoughts, one cannot see that other people also fail to live according to their wishes.

Would happiness continue endlessly if one became the chair of Samsung or Microsoft? Is Bill Gates happy? Are Donald Trump as president of the United States, or Yoon Suk Yeol and Moon Jae-in as presidents of Korea, happy? How many of our presidents were truly happy? Are beautiful, handsome celebrities and wealthy people all happy? When I feel unhappy, I need the experience of examining whether I alone am unhappy and what the lives of others are actually like.

People make extreme judgments when submerged in emotion and thought. They must study themselves and the world more coolly and observe where their emotions came from, why they suffer, and what failure is making life difficult. This study of the mind can help one escape suffering and choosing death because of one’s delusions. I hope this teaching reaches more people, because too many take their own lives due to personal psychological pain.

Yet we must not reduce all of this to a problem of the individual mind. If many people die by suicide because they cannot bear social inequality, then society must solve that problem. If a great wealth gap and dissatisfaction with life produce misery and drive people toward death, we must distribute opportunity more evenly, reduce the gap, and shift as much as possible from an order centered on ownership toward one centered on sharing. It would also be foolish simply to demand that everything be shared unconditionally. People want to be rewarded for their efforts. We must include that desire while changing the extreme and rotten capitalist structure that sickens people and destroys community.

I criticized a society that prohibits physical violence while insisting that violence inflicted with money is not violence. Economic power that says, “You are fired,” or “I will open a store several times larger beside yours and do not care whether you go bankrupt,” is also violence that crushes people. As the age of artificial intelligence arrives, capitalism must change into a newly sharing society, and suicide has an aspect that must be addressed collectively as a social problem.

One viewer said, “It seems like a person trapped in a spiderweb thinks of suicide.” I replied that the fact it is a web the person spun themselves makes the issue terribly difficult. Breaking the views and standards in one’s own head is Buddhism, but it is by no means easy. At times we live in pain because of misguided thoughts. That makes both kinds of work necessary: studying and observing the standards within oneself, and changing the social web that constricts people. Today I spoke in one continuous current about Pyrrhonism as Buddhism transmitted to ancient Greece and about a life that escapes the web of one’s views by asking questions.

AI · EDITED FROM VIDEO CAPTIONS

This article was edited by AI solely from the supplied video captions and description. No external sources were used.