VIDEO ESSAY · ALL ARTICLES

What Are the Buddhist Views of Time and Space? — Arahant Live

READ · QUESTION · VERIFY

Are Some Questions Higher or Lower Than Others?

This conversation began with a cautious question left by a viewer. The viewer asked what Buddhism’s view of time and space is, what the Buddha said about them, and how we should understand time and space. An apology followed the question, however. The viewer said it seemed like a foolish question because it was not the urgent matter of life and death, and worried that repeatedly asking low-level, minor questions might disrupt the lecture.

I want to remove that worry first. When it comes to awakening, questions do not differ in level. Whatever is blocking a person now is the most important question for that person and, in one sense, the most important question in the world. My suffering, my emotions, my life, the problem directly in front of me, the feeling that something is strange, and the doubt that I may be thinking wrongly are genuine hwadu. You do not have to present an impressive gong’an or speak of “the cypress tree in the courtyard” to ask a sophisticated Buddhist question. Rather than grasping impressive-sounding words like flowers in empty space, asking what actually binds me brings me closer to liberation.

The problem that binds me is the most important problem, and the question that asks about it is the most profound question.

This is also why I emphasize dialogue in this livestream. It does not matter whether a question is Buddhist, philosophical, social, about personal suffering, or about an ordinary curiosity. I must bring out the thorn caught in my throat or lodged under my fingernail if dialogue is to change me. I therefore wanted both to answer the question about time and space and to make clear what kinds of questions people may ask in this broadcast from now on.

I Do Not Know What the Buddha Said Time and Space Are

My first answer to “What did the Buddha say?” is simple: I do not know. I will not fill the gap with a guess. A Buddhist scripture may contain statements about time and space, but I cannot be certain that they were actually spoken by the Buddha. Saying that I do not know when I do not know is the starting point of Buddhist study.

Some other schools of ancient Indian thought explain the world by dividing it into independent categories such as time, space, jiva, and ajiva. But if, within our limited observation and cognition, we cut the world into several substances and declare, “The world consists of these,” have we seen truth, or have we arbitrarily reached a conclusion from within our narrow observation? That is the first question we should ask.

The materials I regard as likely to belong to an old stratum of teaching include the Rhinoceros Sutta in the Sutta Nipata, parts of the Atthaka Vagga or the Suttas of Eight Verses, and parts of the Parayana Vagga. Even there, I distinguish passages that appear to be later commentary and additions. Yet I do not declare even these to be the Buddha’s own words. I merely infer that they may be close to what the Buddha meant. In that old stratum, there is almost no attempt to define the substance of time and space. Instead, it deals with the delusions involved in existence and nonexistence, what we believe to be truth, what we think we know, and what we call “I.”

If someone had asked Gautama Siddhartha about the essence of time and space, how would he have answered? My calling myself an arahant does not mean that I know everything about the universe, life, or the mathematics and science that make YouTube work. An arahant is not someone who possesses all knowledge, but someone who knows that he does not know and that his cognition can fall into delusion. Buddhism is not a path toward omniscience through the accumulation of knowledge.

What We Thought We Knew About Spacetime Has Kept Changing

Human ideas about time and space have continued to change. In the past, people sometimes treated time and space as separate and independent. Today, after Einstein’s work, we think about spacetime in terms of relationships. This does not mean that current science has completed the final truth of spacetime. Even after quantum mechanics, we cannot say that we know everything. Present explanations remain hypotheses open to observation and verification, and they can change when new observations and exceptions appear.

We commonly assume that we all live in the same time. Yet the first, thirteenth, and twentieth floors of my apartment building are under slightly different gravitational conditions. Even a person one meter away from me is not in completely identical conditions. GPS cannot calculate an accurate position if it assumes that time passes identically on the ground and on a satellite. It must account for the time differences associated with the satellite’s altitude and speed. The idea that time does not pass uniformly everywhere is already built into the navigation systems we use in everyday life.

When I encountered this material in books in my late forties, I felt as if the ground beneath me were shaking. The worldview I had vaguely assumed I understood—light, gravity, time, and space—crumbled. Science is fascinating in this respect. Yet after that shock, we must not erect the new explanation as another absolute truth. Just as Newton regarded gravity as an invisible force and later explanations changed, today’s conclusions may also be revised before new observations.

Regardless of whether the traditional account of the fourteen undeclared questions is historically factual, the story that the Buddha did not answer questions about the size of the universe, the soul, and what happens after death displays an important attitude: he did not claim to know everything. To me, this is Buddhism’s formidable point. Some of the earliest teachings contain almost none of the cosmological nonsense common in other religions and philosophies of the time. By contrast, later Pali and Chinese scriptures overflow with claims about seeing past lives, reading minds, flying, hell, and rebirth. I regard these as the result of people after the Buddha’s death dressing up their guesses as his words. Because they did not understand Buddhism or awakening, they turned it into a paradise of lies and nonsense.

Dependent Thinking Does Not Carelessly Establish Substances

We should consider why Buddhism so often uses words meaning “not” and “absent,” such as mu, bi, and bul. Non-self means that there is no permanent, independent substance called the self, and impermanence means that nothing always remains the same. Rather than defining and establishing one more new substance, Buddhism asks again whether what we grasp as a substance is really so.

Can we separate space from matter and time and then say, “This is the self-nature of space”? Can we isolate time from every other condition and say, “This is time itself”? From a Buddhist perspective, nothing can exist independently without any relation to, or exchange of influence with, anything else. The same applies to a pen, a finger, a human being, a soul, a body, a mind, consciousness, matter, or space. We name and distinguish them for convenience, but there is no separate, eternal substance corresponding to the name.

Analyzing form, feeling, perception, formations, and consciousness is not a declaration that the universe or a human being consists of five eternal substances. It is a way of taking things apart and observing that there is nothing independent to grasp as “me” or “this.” Nor should we mistake classifications such as earth, water, fire, and air; the Chinese five phases; or the four Western elements for Buddhism’s own final cosmology. They were ways of understanding matter that circulated broadly in the world of the time.

I therefore do not offer the satisfying definition, “Time is this, and space is that.” I do not know either. We can, however, contemplate time and space. What we need then is not a confident declaration but doubt and questioning, together with dependent thinking that sees everything arise and change amid conditions and relationships. The very fact that this answer supplies no gratifying final definition is the Buddhist attitude I am trying to convey.

The Thorn in My Life Is the Most Direct Hwadu

The viewer said that the question about time and space seemed foolish because it was not an urgent matter of life and death. But how many people suffer only over life and death? Many people suffer over other problems and sometimes choose death because of that suffering. Tragically, our pain often arises from everyday conflicts created by delusion and judgment.

Difficulty studying, conflict in romance, friction in family life and at work, a scriptural phrase that makes no sense, or a discrepancy between a monk’s claim and an explanation I heard can all become Buddhist questions. Billions of people on Earth do not suffer from the same problem in the same way. Although we share our humanity, each person’s conditions, experiences, character, and point of blockage differ. That is why I cannot guarantee that the way I awakened will work identically for another person.

When I discuss my own problem, I can directly see, “This is what made me suffer,” or, “I had been treating this standard as fact.” This is the straight path to breaking my frame. Sitting in the mountains for years, removed from life and conflict, does not automatically awaken anyone. Questions arise as we live and collide with other people, and through those questions we can recognize what binds us.

Ask about what makes you curious, what raises doubt, and what does not work in your daily life. Such questions have neither high nor low rank.

If Buddhism does not substantialize anything as “the highest,” then the fixed opposite called “low” does not exist either. The same is true of questions. We should ask confidently rather than hide a question out of fear that it will look foolish. Such questions do not obstruct a lecture; they create the most Buddhist kind of dialogue.

What It Means to Observe the In-Breath and Out-Breath

The next question asked what effect comes from observing the in-breath and out-breath in meditation. Here, observation does not mean occasionally remembering the breath. In anapanasati, sati, translated into our present language, is close to awareness, observation, and knowing. It means knowing that I am breathing in, knowing that I am breathing out, and losing that flow as little as possible.

Breathing in and out, thinking about something else for a long time, and then looking at the breath again is different from continually remaining with it. This is why one counts breaths in a counting practice. If I should count 102 after 101 but forget how far I had counted, my mind has flowed somewhere else. The core does not lie in the breath as a special substance but in sustained absorption in one activity and object.

A person has difficulty holding two different judgments at the same instant. If the pain of having my arm sawed is consuming all my attention, it is hard to continue thinking about the other problem that tormented me moments ago. If I feel depressed after ruining an exam but then play billiards with a friend and concentrate on the balls, thoughts of the exam disappear for a while. The same applies to go, basketball, tennis, fishing, painting, singing, novels, and dramas. While absorbed, the stream of other judgments stops.

Our emotions usually follow a judgment. A person who thinks one must have a romantic partner at Christmas judges his own solitude and becomes depressed. If I cling to the demand that a screen adaptation must follow my wishes, its moving in another direction can become enormous suffering. In the broadcast I mentioned a Japanese manga artist who died after her work was adapted in a direction she did not want, but I did not claim to know her mind or the exact reason. The example was meant to help us consider the relationship between judgment and suffering.

Amid a supervisor’s words, conflict with family, and thoughts racing through past and future, the brain constantly judges and emotions leap about. When I am fully absorbed in the breath, however, I cannot keep that judgment going. The emotional swings subside, and the mind becomes quiet and calm. This can be called an unmoving mind. The same context explains the sense of rest we get from immersion in a hobby. It is not merely an escape from reality. It is a moment that reveals that my judgment that reality should differ from what it is, rather than reality alone, had been tormenting me.

Whether through the in-breath and out-breath, chanting, bows, dance, or music, we can rest for a while if we become fully absorbed in one object. Concentration enters a quiet state in which agitation stops through absorption, and its effect is a deep rest that is difficult to obtain in ordinary life. We must not, however, confuse the unmoving mind of this temporary state with a final condition in which a human being becomes eternally emotionless.

Emotions Still Move Us Even If We Understand Impermanence, Suffering, and Non-Self

The third question asked whether being swept up in emotions in daily life despite understanding impermanence, suffering, and non-self meant that the viewer did not yet understand them fully. Hidden inside this question is the premise, “If I truly understood, emotions should no longer move me.” I question that premise first. Why do you think it is right never to be moved by emotion, and why do you think that is the state of a Buddha?

To give the conclusion first, we are still moved even when we understand impermanence, suffering, and non-self. Suppose my child died in a disaster like the accident at Muan Airport, but I felt no emotion and understood it only rationally. Should that be called a Buddha? If the Itaewon and Sewol tragedies caused no grief or anger at all, what would move anyone to console the victims and challenge broken institutions and power?

The pain of people dying in the war in Ukraine or amid the conflict between Israel and Hamas may not strike me as directly as the death of my own family. Even so, imagining their circumstances and feeling compassion for them requires emotional movement and empathy. Compassion arises from empathy. A cold rationality that has erased emotion cannot produce the activity of a Buddha.

Of course, viewed within a larger flow of conditions, events have causes. The Itaewon tragedy occurred amid conditions involving administration, the police, social institutions, and politics. Yoon Suk Yeol’s becoming the kind of person he is and acting as he did also involved conditions of education, society, the people around him, and his life. Understanding conditions lets us see that an event did not appear without causes and allows us to step back from blind rage. But understanding conditions does not mean that grief, empathy, and responsibility should disappear.

Buddhism is not a religion of becoming a stone. If we call a being who is never moved by any emotion a Buddha, such a Buddha is of no help to the world.

A Buddha is a Buddha because he remains human. Because he knows that delusion caused his suffering, he tells others to leave the cave, recognize rigid thoughts, and become liberated from unnecessary suffering. This is possible because human empathy and compassion remain. Even after awakening, a person feels joy and sorrow and is influenced just like any other human being.

A Buddha Is an Elementary-School Child Who Knows He Is One

What, then, is the difference before and after awakening? I often say, “An arahant is an elementary-school child who knows that he is an elementary-school child.” The human brain responds when the environment seeps into it. Sad music makes us sad, and lively music raises our mood. Movies add sorrowful music to sad scenes, and shops play energetic music. Just as a dog trained to associate a bell with food salivates at the bell alone, people respond to learning and conditions.

Body and mind influence one another, while the conditions of time and space, surrounding people, society, and nature continually change us. An absolutely unmoving mind that no condition can affect is impossible for a living human who exists dependently. Dreaming of such a state is a desire to become a nonhuman, transcendent being. Buddhism is not a path to ceasing to be human.

If I easily become angry with my son but cannot treat a supervisor, a president, or a general the same way, the standards inside me differ by relationship. Emotions arise when circumstances collide with the idea that “my son must obey me,” the habit of shrinking before authority, or the political standards I believe are right. Rather than making the mere fact of anger into a sin, I should ask, “Why did I become angry? Why did I shrink? What had I treated as self-evident?”

Training in concentration and awareness does not eliminate emotion; it changes the way we fall into emotion. When anger arises, there is room not to become anger itself but to see, “I am reacting because of this standard.” Grieving my father’s death is human. But I do not have to remain completely submerged in that one grief for ten or twenty years, nor do I have to behave like an unaffected stone. I can experience grief, know the reaction, and still live wisely.

Awakening Is an Attitude Toward Life, Not a Finish Line

True wisdom lies in observing what a human being is, how I respond, and how the world works according to conditions. We should not imagine a Buddha as someone in whom greed, anger, and ignorance have totally vanished, whose joys and sorrows have ended, and whom nothing can move. We should first ask whether that goal is possible, whether it is human, and how it helps the world. Buddhism does not aim to create someone who sits in concentration all day in the mountains and becomes like a stone.

Emotions naturally arise. What matters is seeing the standard by which I judged, whether I mistook that standard for absolute truth, and whether I am submerged in the emotion, wasting life in hatred and conflict. Human beings absolutize trivial standards, wield knives, and fire missiles even though they may die tomorrow. Wisdom therefore begins with a question.

A Buddha is not a completed finish line but a person who has chosen a direction in life. Such a person recognizes that it is right to live by observing oneself, humanity, and the world dependently, continually asking questions and correcting errors. Even before becoming a perfect Buddha, I can live a tiny bit more wisely than yesterday. If my emotions moved, I should not condemn myself as a failure. I should observe what judgment produced the emotion, ask questions, and contemplate it in terms of conditions. That is the Buddhism that breaks delusion, and it is the conclusion I wanted to convey in this conversation.

AI · EDITED FROM VIDEO CAPTIONS

This article was edited by AI solely from the supplied video captions and description. No external sources were used.