VIDEO ESSAY · ALL ARTICLES

Political Polarization Viewed from a Dependent-Origination Perspective — Arahan’s Live Broadcast

READ · QUESTION · VERIFY

Questions Have No Rank

I wanted this live broadcast to be a time for exchanging questions with viewers, not simply a session in which I explain a topic I chose in advance. If nobody participates, it becomes an hour of me talking alone, and that is not necessarily bad. In fact, I have long made videos about subjects that I thought were poorly understood or widely misunderstood in Korean society and the Buddhist world. Yet the people who come here now have each studied Buddhism in their own way, and they still carry different misunderstandings and doubts. The broadcast takes on a different meaning when we place those doubts before one another.

Some people who want to ask a question worry that it may look foolish or sound too elementary. But in studying Buddhism, there is no separate class of “advanced questions” and “inferior questions.” Dialogue begins the moment we say what we do not know and ask about it. If we are awake for roughly sixteen hours a day, spending one of them together is not a trivial matter. So I want people to ask without hesitation. Today’s conversation likewise unfolded from questions about what the eighteen elements are, how past, present, and future should be understood, how far our community lives from a dependent-origination perspective, what kind of practice I do, what “arouse the mind without dwelling anywhere” means, and whether calming-and-insight contemplation corresponds to samatha and vipassana.

How the Twelve Sense Fields and Eighteen Elements Are Formed

To understand the eighteen elements, we should first look at the sense organs through which human beings receive information about the world and at the objects corresponding to them. The five sense organs—eye, ear, nose, tongue, and body—are named in that order, and adding the mental faculty that notices and distinguishes makes six faculties. To put it roughly in modern language, we can think of the five senses together with the brain activity that notices what they deliver.

Each sense organ has a corresponding object: visible form for the eye, sound for the ear, odor for the nose, taste for the tongue, touch for the body, and mental objects for the mind. The six faculties and six objects together make the twelve sense fields. The eighteen elements add six kinds of consciousness, one for the awareness of each pair. Eye, visible object, and eye-consciousness; ear, audible object, and ear-consciousness; and so on form six sets of organ, object, and consciousness. Six times three makes eighteen, hence the eighteen elements.

Yet I pay attention to the very process by which the numbers increase and every item receives a fixed place. One begins with five sense organs, adds consciousness, and expands the twelve fields into eighteen elements. In my judgment, a fixed system declaring that “the whole is the eighteen elements” belongs to a later stage of Buddhism. For understanding lived experience, it can be enough to begin with the structure of the twelve fields: organs and their objects. The important thing is not memorizing a numbered chart. It is seeing through what a human being encounters the world and how that contact is noticed.

The Past Is Memory and the Future Is Imagination

The question of how to see past, present, and future requires the same kind of observation. We sense the past because we remember. An event that has already gone by is recalled in the present when the brain says, “That happened.” The future has not yet arrived, so thoughts about the future are predictions made through imagination. In actual life, we do not inhabit three compartments called past, present, and future. We always live in the present while remembering and anticipating.

This does not mean that we should stop predicting. It is necessary for life to observe when fish may appear, what happens around the new and full moon, and to plan for tomorrow. But a prediction is not a truth guaranteed with one hundred percent certainty. Logically, we cannot even close off every possibility that the sun might not rise tomorrow. The past is gone, yet we cling to it; the future is absent, yet we grasp it as though it were already settled. Understanding them as memory and imagination leaves us room to use the past and future without being possessed by them.

A Community That Cannot See Dependently and Political Polarization

The question of how far a community’s life departs from dependent origination is extremely broad. It connects to ownership, authority, and good and evil, but I used the political polarization then visible in Korean society as my immediate example. With a Constitutional Court decision concerning President Yoon Suk Yeol approaching, people were divided over impeachment. Even when some people are trapped in misinformation and far-right tendencies, they remain members of the Republic of Korea. The question is why these members cannot talk to one another.

Suppose a family gathers for a holiday. One person is progressive, another conservative, and another centrist. Korea’s two-party system compresses diverse views into two choices and does not adequately represent them. Can relatives who support different parties calmly verify facts and discuss an event? I admitted that my parents-in-law and I differ politically, yet it is difficult even for us to speak openly about issues such as martial law and impeachment. When someone is completely bound to a one-sided source of information and cannot allow that “what I heard may not be true” or “there may be another way to think,” the door to dialogue is shut from the outset.

A person who understands that their knowledge may be wrong and tries to hear other perspectives and other information is already half an arahan.

I say that breaking the frame of one’s thinking through discussion is itself liberation. School education usually trains students to memorize and select the correct answer rather than to doubt a textbook and verify it. When studying mathematics, language, physics, chemistry, or biology, we become accustomed to receiving and using information quickly rather than asking whether it could be wrong. Society likewise divides things into right and wrong, good side and bad side, duties to obey and people to punish. When someone who has lived within that system hears, “The information you know may be wrong,” they take a correction of information as an insult to their very being. They respond, “Are you calling me bad? Are you looking down on me?” Their feelings are hurt before inquiry begins, and the conversation ends.

The problem appears even more starkly in religion. Can one examine a pastor’s words and the Bible critically? Can one examine a monastic’s words and Buddhist scriptures critically? Can one ask how even a professor or Nobel laureate could be guaranteed one hundred percent correct? This is not a Christian problem alone, nor a Buddhist problem alone. A person without religion does not automatically think critically. Korean society strongly dislikes being corrected, and many people have more experience fighting over whose claim is right than conducting a genuine discussion. Society and religion alike are therefore full of rigid “kkondae”—people who turn age, rank, wealth, study, or years of practice into authority.

I also said that, apart from particular people I personally respect, I generally use the plain term “monastic” rather than an honorific. A position does not make a person’s statement true. Whether someone is a religious figure, a professor, or a prizewinner, we must be able to examine both their words and our own thinking critically. Unless we leave an authoritarian culture that hears criticism as a personal attack, political polarization and religious rigidity will keep repeating the same structure.

The Three Axes of Practice as I Describe Them

When asked what practice I do, I give three answers: observe, raise doubts and questions, and reason in terms of dependent origination. This is not a technique confined to a special place. It is a way of living that observes emotions, moods, thoughts, the body, society, and nature together. Simply drifting along in a daze is not observation. Being swallowed by anger or submerged in depression as time passes is not observation either. Observation means bringing awareness to the event and examining it attentively.

Suppose my son knocks over a glass of water. I may burst out, “I told you not to spill it.” Even that brief scene contains a standard that water must not be spilled, a judgment that I should scold my son, the emotion that rises, and the action that follows. An ordinary observer sees the son’s fault but fails to see the standards and judgments through which the observer participated in the event. It is the same problem described in the Sermon on the Mount: seeing a speck in another person’s eye while missing the beam in one’s own. Buddhist observation does not look only at the object. It turns my view, emotion, and action into objects of observation as well.

Depression is no different. I should ask whether I am depressed because I lack money or because I hold the standard that I must have money. I can ask whether I feel miserable because I believe everyone should have a partner at Christmas and imagine that all other college students do while I alone do not. Where did that standard arise? Through what judgment did the emotion appear? Is there truly no way through the situation? The standards and images in our minds were absorbed from society, nature, and experience as we grew. Observation begins when we attend to them rather than leaving them in place as an unquestioned “me.”

After observation comes the question “Why?” Why am I angry? Why am I depressed? Why did this feeling arise? Is what I believe to be fact actually fact? Where did my standard come from? Buddhism without questions is no different from superstition. Finally, we reason through the relationships between causes and results. Emotions, judgments, and views do not spring from nowhere; they arise in dependence on conditions. All phenomena arise according to conditions. If we do not look for causes, we have no path to solving problems. My practice is therefore observation, questioning, and dependent-origination reasoning, through which I repeatedly step out of what I had mistakenly believed.

On the Claim That Seon Meditation Will Save Society

At this point, I became angry at Buddhist slogans claiming that Seon meditation would save humanity and turn “Hell Joseon” into a happy Korea. Meditation can be a personal method of concentrating and resting. But social structures do not change and humanity is not saved merely because everyone enters meditation. When they leave meditation, the unjust conditions remain. Substituting private practice for social reform prevents us from seeing what produced “Hell Joseon.”

Concentration has a role. Focusing on one object stills scattered thoughts, quiets the mind, and offers rest from stress. Yet that function is auxiliary. Social causes involving ownership and power, labor and the economy, discrimination and violence must be changed socially. A person shivering in the cold needs clothing and a warm place, not an order to change their mind. Korea’s long-standing high suicide rate despite its large economy cannot be blamed only on individual mentality. Suffering produced by society must be addressed by criticizing social wrongdoing and changing institutions. This is why I attend to social problems and call wrongdoing by its name.

I therefore criticized Ven. Jinwoo’s claim that Seon meditation could create world peace and save humanity as nonsense spoken by someone who does not understand Buddhism. Enjoying meditation as a hobby or a form of rest is one thing; advertising it as the answer to social problems is another. If inequality, authority, and violence remain after meditation ends, we must directly change the causes and conditions that produce them.

Can Craving Alone Be Fixed as the Cause of Suffering?

The familiar claim that “the fundamental cause of suffering is craving” should also be examined before it is memorized. Depending on how craving is defined, it can be partly right, but it is wrong to say craving itself is always the cause of suffering. If everything I wanted were immediately fulfilled, I would not suffer from that desire. The problem is that the world does not move according to my wishes and that even a president or a corporate tycoon cannot fulfill every wish. Mental suffering in particular grows from the demand that an illusory object must be obtained and from failing to understand the conditions under which it can or cannot be obtained.

Some desires, like eating when hungry, end when satisfied. Yet human beings desire what they lack more than they appreciate what they have. The joy of obtaining one thing is brief, and another desire soon follows. A child receives one toy and seeks another. One begins by wanting to date someone, then wants to hold hands, kiss, have sex, and form a family; even after these things happen, another situation is desired. The conclusion is not simply that wishing is bad. I, too, broadcast because I want to convey something to people. A human being cannot live without preparing for tomorrow and setting goals.

What matters is understanding the conditions and limits of a wish. If I vow, “I will not be happy until every person in Korea becomes a buddha,” I am running into a hell of my own making. I have bound happiness to one outcome that may or may not occur in an impermanent world. Only by being content with small things and understanding the arising and passing of wishes and the person who wishes can I leave the trap made by a mistaken concept.

Why the Four Noble Truths and Noble Eightfold Path Must Be Questioned

A viewer asked whether, if the twelve fields, eighteen elements, and thirty-seven factors were later additions, only the Four Noble Truths and the Noble Eightfold Path would remain as Shakyamuni’s teaching. I answered that the Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path were also systematized after the Buddha’s death and cannot be treated as his own words. The very method of fixing a list and saying “these are the things you must follow” differs from what I take to be the heart of early Buddhism. This can feel like peeling an onion until nothing remains. But Buddhism does not consist in possessing a fixed list. It lies in a person bound in a cave and covered by hardened views recognizing delusion and becoming flexible.

Becoming a buddha or arahan does not erase the human conditions of cognition. Liberation means becoming a person who deeply understands that I am fallible and can be foolish—and who can therefore discuss, keep examining the beam in their own eye, and continue questioning. Observation, questioning, and self-correction remain in place of a fixed answer sheet. This is not a move toward nothingness. It is a move from a dead list to a living Buddhism.

Near the end of the broadcast, I put the Sutta Nipata on screen and explained more of my grounds. The Sutta Nipata belongs to the Khuddaka Nikaya, the collection of shorter and miscellaneous texts within the Pali Nikayas of Theravada, the Southern or Elders’ Buddhism. It is known as one of the oldest forms of Buddhist scripture, yet I see older verses and later explanations combined within it. Chapter Four, the Atthakavagga or Chapter of Octads, contains sixteen discourses. In my reading, discourses two through five—the Discourses on the Cave, the Corrupt, the Pure, and the Supreme—form four original octad texts, while the rest include later commentarial discourses written to explain them. I said that an early form of the Four Noble Truths appears in the eleventh discourse of that chapter and was later developed into the familiar system. The Eightfold Path was then organized within the truth of the path. Thus, in my view, the story that the Buddha delivered the complete Four Noble Truths and Eightfold Path from the beginning in the first turning of the wheel, making the finished system unconditionally true, is a lie.

In Buddhism, what a statement means and whether it can be observed are more important than whether it is “the Buddha’s own word.” Without doubt, we mistake later systems for truths that existed fully formed from the start.

I stressed that I had not invented this account by myself and asked viewers to locate and check the material directly. That was not a request to make one link into a new authority. It was a request to compare sources concerning the Sutta Nipata, the Chapter of Octads, and the formation of the early Four Noble Truths—and to examine my own words critically as well. We should also question the habit of always translating samma as “right” and identifying Buddhism itself with a system of right view, right path, and rule keeping. The Buddhism I see is not a religion of obedience to a correct list. It is a process of excavating the views within oneself that have hardened into “correctness.”

Identity View and the Imagined, Eternally Unchanging Self

To the question whether identity view—the belief that a substantial self exists—is the first ignorance, I replied that the classification called identity view was itself made later. It is nevertheless one important delusion. A person asks, “Who am I?” and quickly answers, “I am this body,” or imagines in the opposite direction that there is a true self or soul apart from the body. Either answer can close the question too quickly.

No eternally unchanging self exists apart from relationships. Mind and body continue to change, and birth and disappearance are changes of form. “Not-self” is not a command to erase oneself nihilistically. It tells us not to imagine a self-existing and changeless substance. The moment we posit such a being and believe “that exists,” we easily rebuild the delusion Buddhism meant to break. We must return to the observation that nothing exists without relations and nothing escapes change.

Fragments of valuable teaching can help a religion endure, but the moment it commands people to believe, it becomes an idol religion that makes them foolish. I see the same form of idolization and following not only in cult leaders but also in political leaders such as Hitler. Buddhism, too, has not avoided the path of becoming a religion of rules and authority. I therefore criticized contemporary Buddhism harshly as having become almost a “Buddhism of fools.”

Why “Arouse the Mind Without Dwelling Anywhere” Conflicts with Dependent Origination

The line commonly rendered “arouse the mind without dwelling anywhere” is widely praised. A story also says that the Sixth Patriarch Huineng heard this line, awakened, and resolved to ordain. Yet I bluntly criticized it as one of the most foolish lines in the Diamond Sutra. The notion that a mind can pop out without relying on anything conflicts with dependent origination.

My broadcasting has reasons, purposes, and wishes. I realized things through a past in which I lived in error and suffered, through books and language, science and philosophy and religion, other people, and society. From this came the wish that others might fall into the same traps less often, and from that wish came the broadcast. This mind did not arise while dwelling on nothing. It arose by relying on countless conditions. An arahan does not produce a mind without purpose, memory, or relation. Human beings live within conditions.

For the same reason, I criticize the Diamond Sutra’s logic when it speaks of immeasurable merit yet ranks giving that expects no merit as the highest form of giving. This does not mean discarding the entire text. At its core is a forceful teaching: do not be bound to appearances; see the views in your head as constructed images; and do not mistake any phenomenon for an absolute truth, because all phenomena are impermanent. Vajra should be read less as the image of a hard diamond and more as a destructive force that smashes delusion like a lightning bolt. That is why I call it the “Lightning Sutra” or “Thunderbolt Sutra.” A single scripture can contain both the power to break delusion and statements that conflict with dependent origination, so every sentence must be read critically.

Will Religion Disappear?

When someone suggested that religion would disappear in the future, I said that I could not decide so quickly. Religion has not vanished in more than two thousand years, and the definition of religion is itself unclear. If religion means only theistic systems that demand belief and the veneration of a leader, my work is different. I do not tell people to believe that I am a one-hundred-percent correct authority.

Even so, I think I am doing religion. I seek what the Buddha’s words might have been, unfold their meaning in present life, and share teachings about people, suffering, and wisdom. The borders among science, philosophy, and religion also change according to their definitions. Before predicting religion’s disappearance, we must ask what this “religion” that is supposed to disappear actually is.

Is Calming-and-Insight Contemplation Samatha and Vipassana?

The East Asian Buddhist term often translated as calming-and-insight contemplation combines “stopping” and “observing.” Stopping is connected to concentration, in which a scattered mind is gathered and stilled; observing is connected to gaining wisdom by examining phenomena. Thus, when asked whether this practice is samatha and vipassana, I answer that despite differences of name and translation, they point in substantially the same direction.

Samatha gathers what is scattered and absorbs the mind in one object. When a person is fully absorbed in a game of Go, thoughts about parents’ nagging, tomorrow’s examination, and money may stop temporarily. Concentration is useful because thought becomes quiet, the mind rests, and agitation decreases. When confronting facts such as death and impermanence, the initial emotions of fear, dread, and aversion may also settle enough to permit calmer and more rational observation. The contemplation of skeletons asks us to see another person’s aging, death, and dry bones and recognize that our death is the same phenomenon, but this can sound cruel. To use the image from the film The Matrix, people accustomed to blue-pill stories about going to heaven or hell and being reborn may react emotionally if suddenly given the red pill: observe directly that people age, die, dry into bones, and disappear. Samatha can serve as an aid that reduces that emotional noise.

But observation is the heart of awakening. Vipassana is attentive observation that separates phenomena carefully and sees through them. Consciousness cannot observe all available information simultaneously, so it must attend to what it is examining. We must distinguish and inspect body and death, emotions and thoughts, standards and judgments, and causes and results. Concentration assists observation, but concentration itself is neither wisdom nor world peace. In calming-and-insight contemplation, or samatha and vipassana, stilling is auxiliary, while observation is the beginning and end of Buddhist practice. Claiming that Seon meditation alone can save humanity reverses this relationship.

Self-Interest Also Exists Only in Relationship

When someone observed that broadcasts satisfying self-interest are more popular, I replied that my broadcast, broadly understood, also satisfies a viewer’s self-interest. If people listen in order to reduce their suffering and live more wisely, they are seeking their own benefit. I do not condemn that outright. But we must ask more deeply what this “self” is.

Could a self that abandoned parents, spouse, lover, siblings, friends, society, and country and remained alone in the universe become happy by satisfying self-interest? Even to be praised or feel that I am the best, I need other people who compare and respond. The self I imagine is constituted within sociality. Self-interest and concern for others are therefore not separate substances; they are interdependent. To understand my benefit properly, I must also see the people and communal conditions that make me possible.

Do Not Believe the List; Verify It Yourself

Today’s questions may look unrelated, but they join into a single stream. Memorizing the eighteen elements, turning past and future into substances, identifying political information with one’s identity, believing meditation will save society, fixing craving as the sole cause of all suffering, treating the Four Noble Truths and Eightfold Path as a complete original sermon, or venerating “arouse the mind without dwelling anywhere” as an unquestionably supreme sentence—all arise when observation and questioning stop.

Observe, question, and reason dependently. Accept that what I know may be wrong and verify it directly. That is the practice and liberation I describe.

My explanation is no exception. Viewers should find the Sutta Nipata material I mentioned and compare it with other sources. Even if I have said something many times, people should ask again when a question remains. An incomplete answer can be supplemented in the next conversation. Something is not to be believed merely because everyone knowledgeable supposedly knows it, nor does truth change because many people do not. When we continue questioning instead of dwelling in authority, we can peel ourselves away from hardened views and move toward a more flexible and wiser life.

AI · EDITED FROM VIDEO CAPTIONS

This article was edited by AI solely from the supplied video captions and description. No external sources were used.