1. I Begin by Questioning the Wish to ‘Let Go of Anger’
This Dharma talk began with a long email from a sixty-five-year-old viewer. The viewer had discovered the channel by chance, was watching through the first season, and wanted to ask about a lifelong concern: how to bring down and extinguish anger, or jine. Most Buddhist books and lectures call greed, anger, and ignorance the three poisons and teach that anger harms the person who carries it. The question therefore seems to arise naturally: ‘How can I eliminate anger?’
I do not immediately offer a technique. I begin with other questions. Is anger always bad? Must a human being truly never become angry? Is a Buddha someone in whom greed, anger, and ignorance have vanished so completely that nothing can move them? Merely repeating an answer heard from someone else is not Buddhism. This talk begins by questioning what we have heard, observing it, and thinking about it critically.
The central issue, then, is not a trick for calming down quickly. It is to ask why anger arises, where the standard behind my anger came from, whether that standard is actually right, and whether this situation calls for expressing anger, withholding it for now, or changing the standard itself.
2. If We Eliminate Anger in the Face of Unfair Labor, Does Justice Disappear Too?
The viewer’s concern was not merely about emotional regulation. Under the employment agreement and the applicable standard at the company, processing 300 cases a month was supposed to be enough, yet the viewer was assigned far more work and received no compensation for the excess. The situation caused both physical and mental suffering. Negotiations with the company produced promises that were not kept, and the conditions continued to deteriorate over a long period. Even trying to think about something else while working did not remove the resentment and anger.
According to the email as I presented it in a partly abridged and summarized form, the viewer has since left the company and escaped the immediate situation, but asks what could have been done while remaining employed and confronting the reality instead of avoiding it. The email also raises a crucial objection in advance. If we say that everything is impermanent, without self, and without substance, or tell the victim simply to change their thoughts and standards, will the same person not continue bearing the loss while social justice disappears?
I do not pass over that objection. This video does not judge whether resigning was right or wrong, nor does it prescribe a specific workplace procedure. The experience does, however, shake the premise that eliminating anger is always good. If a person facing injustice sets no boundary and shows no response, the other party may learn that the same conduct can be repeated. Anger may therefore be not only a poison to discard but also an alarm that detects violation and unfairness.
3. The Anger of the Monkey King and the Anger of a Mother Cat
I first reconsider the inherited convention that anger is poison. In Journey to the West, the Monkey King is portrayed as quick to anger, and the headband used to restrain him tightens and hurts him when he loses his temper. Symbolically, this reflects the later view that anger ultimately injures the angry person. Many Buddhists, teachers, and books today explain anger in this way.
Here I claim that the prototype of greed, anger, and ignorance found in the Palgesonggyeong is presented very differently from the familiar modern convention of the three poisons. In my account, later Buddhism lost sight of the original meaning, the idea that ‘anger must never be expressed’ hardened into an unquestioned doctrine, and that later perspective also entered the story of the Monkey King. We should therefore question the premise instead of automatically treating a familiar doctrine as the original teaching.
But I ask us not to stop there. If my child were harmed by another child at school, should a parent not hold the school system and the other parent responsible and speak forcefully so that the same thing does not happen again? Would a gentle tone always be enough? At times, the intensity of emotion may be necessary to show how serious the violation is and to make clear that the boundary must not be crossed again.
When danger approaches her young, a mother cat glares, raises her tail, and threatens the intruder. When a weaker being has to fight, anger and the force of adrenaline can help it act. A similar force appears in combat, hunting, or intense sport. I see anger not merely as a moral defect accidentally attached to human beings, but as part of a natural system that can protect the self, one’s family, and the vulnerable.
4. At Times, Both Individuals and Societies Must Become Properly Angry
At this point I make clear that this is my view and that others may think differently. With that qualification, I still say there are times when we must strongly warn someone who harms our parents or children never to do it again. If we merely smile and let it pass, that person may see us as a pushover or as weak and repeat the behavior. Anger can announce a boundary and warn against recurrence.
I extend this reasoning to society. I criticize Yoon Suk Yeol’s martial law and the threat made through guns and force, and I present strong social punishment that prevents repetition as one form of society’s anger. I also refer to the death sentence imposed on Chun Doo-hwan and the later forgiveness and pardon, arguing that when society fails to become properly angry at the necessary moment, it may leave behind the harmful lesson that similar conduct is permissible.
A single rule saying, ‘Anger is poison, so never show it,’ is therefore insufficient. There are times when we must become angry to protect ourselves, our parents, our children, our country, and justice. The viewer’s workplace anger should not be dismissed as an abnormal reaction or a sign of insufficient practice. Anger arose because a standard collided with reality and a boundary that needed protection was broken.
5. Yet the Fact That I Am Angry Does Not Prove That I Am Right
I then establish the danger on the opposite side. The fact that anger can be necessary does not make an angry person automatically right. People generally become angry when events violate their standards, or when a wife, child, or subordinate refuses to obey them. In the moment of anger, nearly everyone believes they are right.
Opposing political groups behave in the same way. A person at a conservative rally may believe they are defending the country while condemning the other side, and a person at a candlelight rally may believe their own anger is defending justice. The mere fact that both sides are angry cannot determine which standard is right. The intensity of anger is not proof of truth.
The deeper problem is not anger itself but attachment to the belief that my view is unquestionably right. Once I become incapable of being wrong, I can no longer hear another person, discuss, or debate. We call someone a kkondae when they impose the standards learned over a lifetime on those beneath them and refuse to reconsider. If this certainty hardens further, it can become authoritarian or fascistic. Whenever anger arises, I therefore urge us to ask: ‘What do I believe is right? Where did that standard come from? Is it actually right?’
6. The First Flash of Anger Appears Before Deliberate Thought
Can mastery of the mind prevent even the first arising of anger? I do not think so. When we hear three times three, nine appears immediately; when we hear six times six, thirty-six follows. Someone who drinks coffee every morning looks for coffee upon waking. When the lunch bell rings, hunger and saliva can arise. A dog repeatedly exposed to food and a bell will later react to the bell alone.
Advertising works through the same mechanism. Repeated images portraying a certain car, garment, or brand as admirable plant an image and a standard that make us want it. The urge to drink Coca-Cola upon seeing it, or the saliva produced by the smell of soybean-paste stew, is not something we create through a fresh logical decision in that instant.
Just as an old song can automatically bring back a school-trip bus and the emotions of that day, a situation learned as insulting, unjust, or unfair can make anger flash out like lightning. Repeated experiences, society, and relationships have planted standards in the mind; when a related stimulus appears, memory, emotion, and the body react together. Trying to eliminate this first response entirely by will is like trying to eliminate hunger, memory, and digestion. That is not a way of understanding a human being. It is an attempt to turn a human being into a stone.
7. Do an Unmoving Mind and Concentration Alone Produce Wisdom?
People imagine that advanced practice eliminates greed, anger, and ignorance and leads to an unmoving mind untouched by every stimulus. Deep concentration or samadhi on a single object can produce something that resembles this state. It is like someone completely absorbed in StarCraft who cannot hear a person speaking beside them.
But is an absorption that blocks out one’s surroundings the same as wisdom? Awakening requires questioning, observation, and thought. I use the story of Archimedes as an example. He carried the question of how to measure the volume of an irregular crown, observed how the water level and overflow changed when a body or object entered the water, and arrived at an answer. ‘Eureka’ comes not from ending thought, but from carrying a question while observing and reflecting on what happens.
Questions such as ‘Who am I?’, ‘Where did I come from and where am I going?’, and ‘What are dependent arising, impermanence, and non-self?’ have the same structure. Merely sitting for years in the Himalayas or inside a sealed retreat does not automatically produce wisdom capable of addressing personal and social problems. If concentration on one thing prevents us from seeing, questioning, and thinking about anything else, it may obstruct observation and reflection.
Human beings are continuously changed by relationships, environment, and memory. Music changes the mind; the smell of food changes the body. Dreaming of an immutable human being who is influenced by nothing and in whom greed, anger, and ignorance never arise is not an understanding of dependent arising, impermanence, or non-self. I do not place the goal of practice in becoming an unmoving stone.
8. At Whom Do I Become Angry, and Before Whom Do I Suppress It?
If the arising of anger cannot be eliminated, the next practice is observation. We begin by recognizing, ‘Anger has arisen,’ but we do not stop there. We must examine why this person provoked anger, what standard was struck, at whom we permit ourselves to become angry, and before whom we suppress it.
If my mind contains the standard that ‘a child is beneath me, so I may become angry at the child,’ even a small mistake can provoke an outburst. I mention that my father once used violence against my mother and explain that such conduct became possible because both the era and the individual carried a standard that permitted it. Anger is not a substance that rises independently from within; it appears in forms authorized by an age, a power structure, and a relationship.
The opposite also happens. A person with little power may suppress justified anger because they fear losing their job. If they hold back before the powerful and then pour the anger onto a child, spouse, or subordinate at home, the result is not righteous anger but anger distorted by power. Without observation, a person can become submissive before the strong and authoritarian toward the weak.
I become angry too. Understanding through dependent arising that another person acted under certain conditions does not automatically erase my judgment that the action should not have happened, nor the anger associated with that judgment. Understanding causes and holding conduct responsible can coexist. What matters is that I do not sanctify my own anger as absolutely right, but examine it again through its causes and consequences.
9. Should I Express It, Withhold It, or Change the Standard?
If the viewer’s company acted unfairly, anger is natural. Yet if we become submerged in the emotion and act immediately simply because anger has arisen, we may create greater harm for ourselves and others. I therefore ask us, after anger appears but before turning it into action, to examine whether the standard is right and what consequences the action will produce for ourselves and the world.
First, there are times when we should express anger against authority and injustice even at some cost to ourselves. This is anger that protects oneself, family, and the vulnerable; warns the other party not to cross the boundary again; and resists the repetition of social wrongdoing. Here anger becomes the force of warning and action.
Second, when immediate expression would bring greater loss or danger, we may recognize the anger and still withhold or regulate it for the time being. This is neither pretending that anger does not exist nor glorifying unconditional endurance as maturity. It is a choice made by examining the actual balance of power and the likely consequences.
Third, if the standard beneath the anger is wrong, the standard itself must change. None of these choices can become an absolute rule for every situation. I am not saying always become angry, always endure, or abandon every standard. Wisdom is observing and choosing among expression, temporary restraint, and revision of the standard according to what helps oneself, other people, and the world in the present situation.
10. A Child Is Not Property, and a Standard Can Be Reconditioned
As a clear example of a standard that must change, I discuss the belief that a child is a parent’s possession. If a parent thinks, ‘I gave birth to this child, so the child is mine,’ the parent may refuse to recognize the child’s independent will and imagine a right to become angry whenever the child resists. Even the extreme act of a parent ending both their own life and the child’s can contain the possessive standard that fails to see the child as an independent living being.
A child is born through the parents but is not their object. The child is an individual who will live one life of their own. Once this is observed, the foundation of the anger provoked by the child’s failure to meet the parent’s standards can change. The answer here is not to endure the same anger more skillfully, but to become free of the standard that produced it.
Standards planted by society also change. A person conditioned by the old rule that boys and girls from the age of seven should not sit together may become morally angry even at the sight of young boys and girls sharing a space. But as time, place, and experience change, that standard can change too. Someone who learned to see smoking as attractive can repeatedly encounter and experience its harm until the standard of wanting cigarettes is reconditioned into aversion.
Dependent arising, impermanence, and non-self are not arguments for saying, ‘Injustice has no substance, so endure it.’ They help us understand that a standard we considered absolute arose through conditions and can change through other conditions. We may defend a standard that deserves protection and become angry on its behalf, while changing a wrongly learned standard through observation and new experience.
11. We Do Not Eliminate Anger; We Choose Whether to Be Carried Away by It
We can now return to the viewer’s original question. The viewer asked how to eliminate jine, but my answer is not a method for removing it completely. When conditions meet, the first anger may appear as an automatic reaction. Practice is not a technique that prevents the reaction from arising; it creates the possibility of choosing whether to be swept away by it or to pause and examine it.
First, I see, ‘Anger has arisen.’ I ask what struck my standard, where that standard came from, and whether it is actually right. I examine why I believe I may become angry at this person, whether I am discharging anger suppressed elsewhere onto an unrelated weaker person, and what consequences expression will produce now.
Then, if necessary, I deliberately express anger. If necessary, I regulate and withhold it. If the standard is wrong, I correct the standard. Observation is not passively staring at an emotion. It is an active practice of examining causes, power relationships, and the consequences of action so that one can choose wisely. My answer to the viewer is not, ‘Do not feel anger,’ but, ‘Do not become buried in anger; observe the anger and its standard, and choose your action.’
12. Liberation Is Repeatedly Becoming Free of Rigid Standards
If I believe my standard is unconditionally right, no other person’s words can enter. I then become fascistic, authoritarian, or a kkondae. Even someone who studies Buddhism can turn ‘You must not become angry’ into an absolute doctrine and become a Buddhist kkondae. I therefore question that doctrine itself: Where did it come from? Is it always right? What is anger, and why does it arise?
Delusion appears when we seize a conditioned phenomenon that changes across time, place, and relationship as absolute truth. Liberation, as I describe it, is not a finished state in which one is never moved again. It is the repeated act of discovering a hardened thought or standard and becoming free of it. We question the standard that authorized our anger toward a child, spouse, or subordinate, release it if it is wrong, and keep revising it before new observations.
I explain this attitude with the image of a frog in a well. It is to understand that the world I see and know may be only the inside of my well, not the whole world. Humility arises naturally in a person who does not imagine that they possess absolute truth. When speaking of a Buddha or an arhat, I place the weight not on an authority who owns every answer but on an attitude that knows its limits, continues to observe, and continues to become free.
Humility does not mean bowing before every wrong. In a necessary situation, we may become angry even while knowing that it could cost us something, and we must correct violence and anger generated by a false standard. The practice of liberation is to protect what must be protected without turning one’s own standard into an absolute, and to keep examining that tension.
13. Buddhism Is Not Becoming a Stone; It Is Asking Questions
Anger cannot be eliminated completely. Like hunger, the memories called up by an old song, or the bodily process by which food is consumed and later expelled, anger arises when causes and conditions meet. Mind and body exchange influences with environment and relationship. My anger affects my wife, and her response affects me in return. If my standard changes, something that once provoked anger may cease to do so.
Our task is therefore to see the causes, occasions, and conditions. We observe what conditioned us to hold this standard, what delusion we may inhabit, toward whom the anger is directed, and what result it will produce. We raise questions and reflect. Through that process, we express the anger that needs expression, regulate the anger that needs restraint, and change the standard that needs revision.
It was natural for the viewer to become angry after experiencing unfair treatment. There is no need to blame oneself for failing to erase that anger. At the same time, the mere fact that anger has arisen does not make one’s standard and action absolutely right. We must observe the conditions, standards, and consequences of the anger and make a wise choice in each situation.
Buddhism is not the study of becoming a stone untouched by every influence. Nor is it the study of accepting an answer heard from someone else and stopping there. It asks, ‘Is that really so?’ It observes the self and the world, thinks, and repeatedly becomes free of delusion. My final answer to the wish to let go of anger is not to erase anger, but to observe deeply enough not to be ruled by it and to keep questioning until the end.
This article was edited by AI solely from the supplied video captions and description. No external sources were used.