VIDEO ESSAY · ALL ARTICLES

Awakening Does Not Go Backward — Understanding Buddhism, Episode 12

READ · QUESTION · VERIFY

Previously I discussed the once-returner and why that state can fall back into the desire realm. Before explaining how a once-returner becomes a non-returner, one important characteristic must be established: awakening does not move backward.

This does not mean that someone who awakens remains forever in a bright and peaceful mental state. The life of a stream-enterer can darken again. Liberation of mind may seem to vanish, and outwardly the person may look little different from someone who has never awakened. Even so, awakening does not retreat. My first awakening shows why.

Knowledge that changes an entire life

A stream-enterer is someone whose life has been wholly changed by an experience. Why does life change? Because something previously unknown becomes known. A person has suffered without understanding why, then suddenly recognizes, “This is what caused my suffering.” This is not the addition of one abstract fact. Life as a whole changes through the knowledge.

One of the first things to appear is repentance. People often imagine repentance as countless bows or a confession of sins. Genuine Buddhist repentance, however, comes from seeing what I did not know and how that ignorance made me suffer. “I did not know this. Because I did not know, I lived like that.” Tears flow naturally when this is seen.

Blaming poverty, parents, and circumstance

I had my first awakening while at university in 1994. I wished my family were not poor. I thought my present poverty was the fault of parents, family, and environment, and that I would be happy if the household were rich or confident if my parents had helped me more. Because the pain appeared to be caused outside me, I wanted the external conditions to change.

Yet resentment cannot make a family suddenly wealthy. Blaming one’s parents cannot instantly give them money. While studying impermanence, I saw that the world is already as it is; my refusal to accept a fact does not change it. A rock sunk in a river does not rise because I command it to float.

Looking back, I found this pattern everywhere, especially in blaming others. I may hate aging, but age advances and the world is impermanent. As a child, I did not want to leave a close friend, but when my parents moved I had to go with them. The separation hurt for a long time. Conditions change and separation occurs; my refusal to accept it compounded the suffering.

Repentance in which the past breaks apart like dust

When I saw this, scenes from the past returned one after another like a film or panorama. Here I had suffered for one reason; there I had suffered because of a particular thought. Each scene brought the recognition that I had failed to know what was actually so.

The attachments and ideas accumulated over the years broke apart like dust. Tears streamed as the past played back. This is repentance born from direct seeing. When an unknown fact becomes completely known, liberation through wisdom occurs, and liberation of mind arises with it. That is entry into the stream, the first awakening.

A bright mind can fade

Life does not remain unbroken happiness after stream-entry. The duration varies by person: a month, three months, six months, perhaps more than a year. A bright and vigorous mind gradually darkens, and life may appear similar to the period before liberation of mind.

From outside, someone may say awakening is nothing remarkable. Internally, however, a decisive difference remains. A stream-enterer does not forget the fact that was seen with certainty. The brightness of the mind may vary, but in the area already seen this person differs sharply from others.

It is like removing one patch from a sheet of black paper

Imagine self and world covered by a sheet of black paper. Once one patch is peeled away and its contents seen, that patch does not turn black again. A fact understood completely need not be discovered again and does not revert to ignorance. This is what it means to say that awakening does not go backward.

Why, then, does the mind fall into the desire realm? Because the rest of the paper remains dark. If everything were known in a single moment, one would be a Buddha. We still possess unknown regions concerning self and world, and through them attachment and disturbance return.

Someone who has known liberation of mind cannot be satisfied with darkness

A stream-enterer nevertheless possesses a crucial difference: liberation of mind has been experienced once. One knows how good it is. With a free mind, study and work improve and relationships become easier. I joke that even romance goes better, but the point is real: the whole of life changes.

Someone who loses liberation of mind therefore longs for it. Ordinary life in the desire realm becomes unsatisfying. Eventually one recognizes another attachment and another ignorance. A new section of the black paper is removed, liberation through wisdom and liberation of mind occur again, and the person rises. Brightening, darkening, seeing anew, and brightening again repeat as practice advances.

Someone who has seen not-self is not the same after falling

The fall from once-returning may resemble the fall from stream-entry as a mental state, but the range already seen is different. Someone who has embodied not-self, known concentration and liberation, and examined the most fundamental question—Who am I?—has removed most of the black covering.

Even if that person falls back into the desire realm, the facts already seen do not vanish. One may leave liberation of mind and become entangled in another attachment, but the understood area remains visible. This is why someone who has awakened inwardly differs whether or not liberation of mind is presently active. In that domain the person knows certainly, and this creates a difference in life and society.

Complete understanding changes the channel through which thought flows

Someone who has once repented, undergone a transformed life, and known liberation through wisdom and of mind will eventually reach the next awakening. A fact understood completely remains. Just as one need not relearn that one plus one equals two, the person does not return to the beginning. Whether the mind is dark or bright, insight remains within and continues reshaping life.

The knowledge of liberation strikes with great force. If thought has flowed along one path for years, new insight falls like lightning and opens another route. Only then does the old mistaken channel become visible, and even when thought tries to return there it no longer flows as before. The current itself has changed direction.

Awakening does not move backward. Yet everything is not known at once, so unknown regions can still darken the mind. Such darkness does not erase earlier insight. It reveals the ignorance that must be seen next. Once this characteristic is understood, the movement from once-returning to non-returning becomes much clearer.

AI · EDITED FROM VIDEO CAPTIONS

This article was edited by AI solely from the supplied video captions and description. No external sources were used.