A Live Broadcast for Honest Questions and Cracking One Another’s Heads Open
I began the March 11 live broadcast by greeting Daous, Heowonkkot, Yeonbyeon Jungsu-bu, Kimchimu, Cheongpo, and the others who had arrived early. We started lightly, talking about the warmer weather and how pleasant it had become to take a walk. I explained that there was a delay between the broadcast and the chat and asked viewers to keep that in mind. I then made one clear request of everyone taking part in the chat: do not feel pressured to write the correct answer. Write honestly what you actually think right now.
I regard the people who come here as companions on the path. If companions deceive one another, say only what will make them look good to me, and select the answer that a person in authority would like to hear, where could Buddhist study even begin? If you hide what you think and put your dignity first because you are older, highly educated, or socially prominent, you cannot see yourself. Buddhism begins with honesty. Of course, if you speak and act too differently from the standards of the world, you may look like an eccentric or a lunatic. I am not unaware of that risk. Even so, this channel was never the broad road. It is a narrow gate.
I criticize the authority of mainstream Buddhism, religion, and philosophy. Neither the Supreme Patriarch nor the administrative head of the Jogye Order is exempt, and I do not revere someone’s words merely because that person is a president or professor. If I cannot accept something Seongcheol Sunim said, I question it too. I do not look at a person’s title; I look at whether the words fit life and reality. Anyone who enters this broadcast should therefore question me and question themselves rather than memorize my words as the correct answer. We have not gathered to trade pleasant compliments. We are here to crack one another’s delusions—and our heads—open.
In the past I uploaded about 180 one-way videos. Videos in which I organize and convey what I have read and thought are necessary too, but they make it hard to see where a viewer’s mind is getting stuck. During a live broadcast, when someone asks a question, I turn that question back into another question. I ask what they like and dislike, why they take something for granted, and by what standard they divide right from wrong. The purpose is not to show off difficult Buddhist or philosophical terminology. The purpose is to use a question to make people observe their own thoughts and emotions.
As the main broadcast began, I invited people to raise anything at all: a social issue, a personal concern, a book they had read, or some other interest. I joked that if no one had a question, I could ramble on about the history of philosophy, or I could sit there like an idiot, breathing without saying a word for thirty minutes. My channel is a place where the host can do that sort of crazy thing—just stare at the screen in silence during a YouTube livestream. It was a joke, but it also meant that I considered the questions actually arising here and now more important than a prepared lecture.
How Should Bisang-Bibisang Be Used in Reality?
Daous then asked, “How should bisang-bibisang be understood in the real world, and how should it be applied?” I answered that this was not an unfamiliar subject appearing for the first time today. What I had been talking about nearly every day was, in fact, the practical application of bisang-bibisang. People learn the meditative attainment called bisang-bibisang-cheojeong only as the name of a very high stage, imagining it as a special realm that one encounters by climbing upward from below. That is why they fail to see it in everyday speech and relationships.
People say that the Discourse on the First Turning of the Dharma Wheel contains a story in which someone learns bisang-bibisang-cheojeong from another person and attains it. I do not regard that as historical fact. In my judgment, stories made up in that fashion became mixed into the scriptures. Expressions such as “All marks are not marks; thus one sees the Tathagata,” “all phenomena bear the mark of emptiness,” and “all conditioned phenomena are like dreams, illusions, bubbles, and shadows” are not separate secret incantations either. I see all of them as different ways of pointing in the same direction: do not grasp marks and dharmas as substantial realities. This interpretation of texts and history is the claim I offered during the broadcast. I am not presenting it here as an externally established fact.
I also reject the interpretation that lines up the immaterial attainments after the four meditative absorptions of the form realm and asks whether the attainment of nothingness or bisang-bibisang-cheojeong is higher. I said that Buddhism does not awaken to a stage higher than these but to the whole that includes them. These are not independent stages; they are expressions that view the same reality from different angles. Seen through dependent origination, everything arises according to conditions. Seen through impermanence, nothing is permanent. Seen through non-self, there is no fixed “this.” Seen through bisang, the marks and names we apply possess no independent substance. My explanation was that bisang-bibisang-cheojeong, dependent origination, impermanence, and non-self speak of the same reality. The instruction not to be bound by dharmas, and the description of conditioned phenomena as dreams, bubbles, and shadows, are other windows illuminating that same reality.
We therefore cannot answer Daous by stopping at the memorization of a hierarchy of meditative stages. We must look at what to say to the person before us, whether to shatter what the other person believes or leave that belief untouched for now, and how to use promises, ethics, and manners. The questions that followed showed precisely that practical application.
Should We Tell Beginning Buddhists Only What They Want to Hear?
A viewer who appeared to be Haeam Sunim asked the first question. Beginners make the difficult effort to come to a temple because they want to understand Buddhism, but many meet an unfriendly monk, hear only difficult words and explanations, or, at the other extreme, encounter nothing but stories of special experiences and prayers for worldly blessings. The question was how I would introduce Buddhism to a beginner if I were a monk.
If you tell someone only what they want to hear, they merely confirm their own belief and go home. Yet if you pour out nothing but unwelcome words at the first meeting, the door of the mind slams shut. You have to enter through what interests that person while causing one small doubt to arise within it. A conversation should make them ask themselves why they want it, whether what they currently believe is true, and whether their way of pursuing happiness may instead be producing suffering. Meeting someone within their interests is not the same as pandering to them.
If a person comes to a temple wanting only experiences, miracles, divine aid, the power of prayer, and stories about previous lives, and you keep supplying those things, is that person practicing Buddhism, or merely believing what they want to believe under the name of Buddhism? I think many people in Korea who say they believe in Buddhism are actually practicing a religion of worldly blessings. When I said, “There is no rebirth,” or uploaded a video criticizing what Dr. Jeon Hyeon-su had said, hostile comments appeared: “Who are you to criticize him?” and “You’re a bad bastard headed for an evil realm.” These responses used the name of Buddhism but shut down questions in order to protect belief.
I said bluntly that if I really were a monk, I might drive out anyone who wanted nothing but worldly blessings and tell them not to pray. I even referred to a Buddha statue in an aggressively extreme way before asking, “Was that too much?” People love a story such as Wonhyo’s skull water, yet refuse to hear a single word that might crack their own delusion. It makes me angry enough to ask why on earth they practice Buddhism. But that very anger and hard line will later become another mark that must be examined again.
When I met people in Buddhist circles, some excused superstition as an expedient means and said that we should give people words they enjoy hearing. I cannot compromise when I hear things like that, so I now deliberately avoid many of those meetings. I have no talent for coating my tongue with honey. On a public YouTube channel, I therefore chose the role of saying, even coldly, “What is not so is not so.” Yet not everyone is in the same situation. With one person, a relationship may begin through words they want to hear. Another may need words that invite them to think through their immediate problem in a Buddhist way. Still another may need a shocking sentence. There is no fixed formula for that choice.
A Dialogue About Do-ol’s “Buddhist Bullshit” and His Account of Neo-Confucianism
Heowonkkot then asked a question. The viewer had personally heard Dharma talks by monks discussed on the broadcast and largely agreed with my criticism, but had been shocked to hear me call repeated expressions in the scriptures “bullshit.” Do-ol, the viewer said, had offered an interpretation to the effect that “Neo-Confucianism was born because of Buddhist bullshit.” What did I think about that?
I answered that this explanation had things backward. I had encountered some of Mr. Do-ol’s books and broadcasts about the Diamond Sutra and Christianity, but in my view his understanding of Buddhist fundamentals was not sufficiently deep. That did not mean I wanted to curse the man recklessly. I hesitated briefly over how to address him and settled on “Mr. Do-ol.” What I was criticizing was not his name or authority but that interpretation.
The historical interpretation I presented on the broadcast was this. Religious elements within Buddhism—rebirth, souls, heavenly deities, and the mysteries of practice—may have influenced Daoist currents such as immortals and the art of making elixirs. Yet Buddhism also moves in the opposite direction: it loosens attachment to dharmas, examines impermanence, non-self, and dependent origination, and turns contemplation inward. I believe these conceptual and practical dimensions also influenced Daoism and Confucianism, and I read that influence in central parts of the Daodejing and Zhuangzi as well. In other words, if one extracts only a fictive element of Buddhism and calls it the cause of Neo-Confucianism’s birth, one muddles together the different kinds of influence Buddhism exerted.
I tried to recall a four-character Confucian expression, but the exact wording would not come to mind. A viewer supplied what sounded like “goeryeok-nansin” in the chat, and I accepted the prompt and continued. What I wanted to say was that the development of Neo-Confucianism should be examined not simply as a reaction against Buddhist “bullshit,” but together with the influence of ways of looking at existence and concepts, inward contemplation, and practice.
There was, however, a clear limit. I had not watched the particular Do-ol broadcast to which the questioner referred. If I went on criticizing him without knowing the context in which he had actually spoken that sentence, I too would become someone pretending to know what I did not know. So I stopped rather than pursue the point further. Even when I state my position forcefully, it is right to stop where I have not checked the material.
“This Is Not a Place That Reads Saju Fortunes”
Haeam Sunim then described something that had actually happened at the temple. A Buddhist who had attended the temple where Haeam Sunim was serving for ten years asked one day to have a saju fortune read. Haeam Sunim answered, “This is not a place that reads saju fortunes.” The person replied, “What kind of monk doesn’t even know saju?” and left the temple. Haeam Sunim said the incident had left him feeling some kind of way.
I saw this question itself as the practical application of bisang-bibisang that Daous had asked about. It is not enough to confirm our knowledge that saju is not Buddhism and stop there. Why did the other person assume that a monk should know how to read saju? Had that expectation arisen because many Korean temples and monks had talked about the Four Pillars of destiny and the Five Phases? Behind one individual’s ignorance stand practices and relationships formed over a long time. That does not lead to the conclusion that the practice exists and monks should therefore keep reading fortunes. The point is to see those complex conditions together.
The Red Pill and the Blue Pill, Between Facts and Sweet Talk
I asked the audience: do you prefer the red pill or the blue pill? Do you prefer unvarnished facts, or sweet talk that pats you on the head? Most people like the image they want to see and the words they want to hear. If you tell someone prone to anger, “You get angry easily,” or say that their appearance or abilities are not as exceptional as they imagine, will they be pleased? People are attracted to those who talk up their strengths rather than their weaknesses and make them feel important.
The roughly 180 videos I made are generally closer to red pills. To someone who believes in rebirth, I ask, “There’s no such thing. There isn’t. I’m telling you, it isn’t there. Is that thing really there?” I speak similarly about heaven, souls, and mysterious experiences in practice. With someone who voluntarily comes to my channel willing to hear that kind of speech, I can ask questions that crack the head open. But can I apply that method identically to every person and every relationship?
My Father’s Ancestral Rite: Should I Give My Mother the Same Red Pill?
I offered an example from my family. My father died in 2020, and my elderly mother, whose health is not good, performs his ancestral rite. Because I do not believe that souls exist, would it always be right to tell her flatly that I do not think my father’s soul returns to eat the food, reject the rite, and refuse to take part myself? Just because I hand out red pills on my broadcast, if I force one on a mother who does not want it, am I giving her happiness or adding to her suffering?
I do not think my father’s soul returns on the day of the rite and eats the food. But I can still take time to remember my father and reflect on the fact that I was born and have lived within the conditions and relationships formed by my father and mother. I can use the form of an ancestral rite as a tool for memory and relationship without believing that the form possesses some eternal substance. That is not the same as conceding that a falsehood is a fact.
That is why I said there is no correct answer. There is not always a simple line between a truth that must be spoken and a truth that is better left unspoken right now. When the person, situation, and relationship change, the appropriate attitude may change as well. On the broadcast I emphatically say, “What is not so is not so,” but I do not grab every passerby and shout, “There’s no rebirth! There’s no heaven!” Does refraining from that mean I have betrayed the truth? Conversely, if I tell no one, am I neglecting the role I should play? Wisdom begins here.
A person who comes voluntarily seeking wisdom and liberation may need a forceful question. Just as I smash my own damn head open, some words strike like a thunderbolt and become the condition that shatters a delusion. But if I charge at people who do not want to hear me and insist on breaking their heads too, how can I simply assume that approach is wise? How many people among humankind want the red pill exactly as it is and are truly ready to receive it? The percentages I throw out on the spur of the moment are not statistics. They are rough rhetoric expressing how rare such readiness appears to me.
A Clear Mirror and Still Water: First Quiet the Shaking Mind a Little
I connected this point to the reason Buddhist practice begins by discussing stopping, or meditative concentration. In the realm of desire, we like and dislike, declare things right and wrong, become elated when praised, and grow angry when criticized. When such emotional waves keep rising, it is difficult to see the facts before us as they are. We must first calm that turbulence a little in order to see more coolly.
A sea or lake under a strong wind reflects distorted images of what surrounds it. When the waves grow still, things appear somewhat more distinctly. The phrase “a clear mirror and still water” does not describe a state in which nothing remains. It describes a state in which what is present appears with less distortion. Meditative concentration is not the permanent and total elimination of emotion and thought. It first quiets some of the ripples of liking and disliking, making room to see why I became angry, what I fear, and what expectation I have been carrying.
Haeam Sunim’s saju incident must be reconsidered in just such a state. One may possess the knowledge that “saju is not Buddhism.” But how to answer when a person who has attended for ten years makes that request must be viewed from several sides. Similar events will occur again. Rather than automatically pulling out a single doctrinal sentence every time, one should first examine how clear the mind is that reflects the situation.
Bisang: Knowing That a Mark Is Not a Mark
I now explained bisang more directly. Bisang means knowing that a mark is not a mark. From the perspective that all phenomena are without self, it asks whether anything we name possesses a fixed, independent substance. Are the boundaries called birth and disappearance really fixed and separate? What are dirtiness and cleanliness? What is a tree? What am I? What is a god? What are rebirth and karma? Does any such thing truly exist by its own power, never changing?
By giving it the name “tree,” we can point to an object. But that name is not the tree’s eternal essence. The word “I” is also a name applied to a flow of body, memory, relationships, and conditions. It does not mean that we have found a substance standing apart from all those things and remaining forever the same. Gods, souls, rebirth, and karma do not become independent substances merely because people talk about and share them. Bisang breaks marks open in this way and stops us from mistaking a concept for reality itself.
Bibisang: Does the Lack of Substance Mean Throwing Away Every Tool of the World?
Yet if we grasp only bisang, we veer to another extreme. If age, culture, morality, law, promises, and views possess no inherent substance, may we live any way we please? If precepts are not absolute entities, does it not matter if we kill people and lie habitually? Can we disregard whatever society regards as wrong merely on that basis? The moment we clutch the statement “there are no marks” as a new mark, bisang itself becomes another dogma. That is why bibisang is necessary.
Laughter, kindness, anger, language, and writing are marks that human beings learn and agree to use together. No individual word is ultimate truth, but words become tools that point in a direction. I briefly mocked the kind of authoritative performance that treats a look alone as though it had transmitted an entire Dharma teaching. The exact imitation and wording were not clear enough to carry further. My narrower point was that words are not truth, but communication does not therefore happen automatically without language.
When I speak with Koreans, I use Korean, generally use honorific speech, and make use of socially shared manners and ways of speaking. I do not do so because they are eternal truths. I do it because they are tools that increase the possibility of conveying my meaning to another person. I have already criticized the Supreme Patriarch, Dr. Jeon Hyeon-su, several professors whose names were not clearly audible, and even figures such as Beopjeong Sunim without restraint. Some people left for that reason alone. If I added informal speech, anger, and curses directed at everyone, no one would listen, regardless of what I was trying to communicate. If I boast that I have destroyed marks while also destroying the conditions for communication, whom are my words for?
Bisang-bibisang in reality is the problem of discerning what to take up and what to set aside, whether the other person is willing to listen, and what kind of connection has brought us together. We use the function a concept performs under particular conditions without believing that concept to be a substantial reality. The same is true of language, manners, law, precepts, and roles. There is no fixed answer. We must judge wisely each time.
Refusing the Saju Request, Asking a Question, or Turning Toward Another Conversation
There is more than one possible response to a person who comes for a saju reading. You can immediately say, “Saju is not Buddhism.” Alternatively, you can ask, “Why do you want your saju read?” and let the person’s anxiety and desire emerge. Even if you know little about saju, you might begin with a kind of conversation familiar to that person and then turn toward wisdom about how to view a life. You might offer advice that sounds outwardly like talk about saju but actually invites reflection on attachment and choice.
I did not conclude that one of these responses had necessarily been the one to choose. The idea of using saju as packaging was not a definitive prescription either, but a thought experiment. More important was for Haeam Sunim to examine his own mind at the time. I could not determine that feeling from the outside. I said he himself should observe what he had wanted, what he had regarded as right, and what he had placed at the center of the encounter.
Using an impromptu example that perhaps half of the population is religious, I said that religious people are not the only ones who believe in superstition. People with no religion also live as if money, success, and their own views possessed inherent substance. In my agitation I even said, “99.9 percent of humanity is wandering through a dream.” That was not a researched statistic. It was my exaggeration for the way nearly everyone lives inside delusions of their own.
Viewed that coldly, one cannot say there is an enormous difference between Haeam Sunim, who has not completely awakened, and the person who asked about saju. I did not say this to insult Haeam Sunim. At the very least, Haeam Sunim was openly presenting his concern as a companion on the path and asking the question together with us. The shared space for such dialogue is a real difference. My point was that ordination and knowledge of Buddhist terms do not entitle someone to divide the other person into one who is completely unawake and themselves into one who knows completely.
“It Left Me Feeling Some Kind of Way” Is the Key to Practice
Along the way I greeted Seong Jae-hui, Kim Yong-se, and Do Yun-san-cheon. Someone commented, “Gautama Siddhartha must have worried about things like this too.” I answered that anyone might face such concerns in relationships, but I could not know what Gautama Siddhartha actually worried about. There is no need to pretend to know the mind of someone we do not know. Then I returned to Haeam Sunim’s final sentence.
“I felt a bit unsettled.”
I said this was the most important statement of all. I could not know exactly what emotion the phrase named, and I could not decide its content from the outside. But Haeam Sunim himself could directly observe the fact that a mixture of judgment, decision, and emotion had produced that state of mind.
Why did that state of mind arise? Why? What did he want? How had he expected the Buddhist visitor to behave? What did he regard as properly Buddhist, and what did he regard as wrong? Where did that standard come from? Turning these questions back inside oneself is practice. One does not stop after passing judgment on whether the visitor was wrong; one looks at the marks and expectations the incident exposed within oneself. I thought the brief sentence “It left me feeling some kind of way” could become a key to liberation.
My Mission to Deliver Red Pills Is Another Mark Too
Here I turned the arrow toward myself as well. I attack YouTube Buddhism for lying every time it opens its mouth and spewing one stream of bullshit after another. I therefore think I must deliver the red pill and break people’s delusions. But is that sense of mission not another mark? If I rush out believing that I must awaken everyone, I suffer, the other person suffers, and the task is impossible to begin with.
People ultimately have to see for themselves. All I can do is provide the condition of a question and words. I cannot make someone receive what they do not want. The person who might give the rice cake has not even thought of doing so; my noisy announcement that I am offering a red pill will achieve nothing if the other person will not open their mouth. Conveying what I take to be true must therefore go together with examining whether the other person is prepared to receive it.
I then moved through a rough passage about the way people turn familiar judgments about desire, anger, foolishness, or outward composure into fixed marks. Someone gets angry and people instantly conclude that the person’s practice is shallow; someone smiles calmly and they declare the practice deep. Oh, give me a break. That standard is another mark too. Yet if I claim to have destroyed the mark and therefore curse everyone and behave however I please, the message will not get through. Conventions such as honorific speech, a calm expression, and a smile are not independent truths, but they can be used as conditions for talking with another person. Recognizing a mark is different from abolishing its function.
Promises, Laws, and Names Are Conditional Tools, Not Substantial Realities
Consider a promise. Even if I promise to meet you tomorrow, I cannot guarantee that tomorrow I will be alive and able to arrive at that place. I may suddenly become ill, or something unforeseen may happen. Yet if I say, “The future cannot be guaranteed, so every promise is false,” and keep none of my promises, transactions, conversation, and communal life become impossible. A promise possesses no independent and unchanging substance, but the good faith of trying to keep it is necessary for society and relationships to continue.
The same is true of precepts, laws, etiquette, language, and names. Human beings create and share them according to conditions for the sake of convenience, so they are not eternal. Yet within those conditions they perform real functions. The name “tree” is not a tree’s essence, but we need it to point out a tree and work together. A law may not be absolute truth, but it becomes a device for preventing people from casually killing or deceiving others. Bisang keeps us from turning such things into inherent realities; bibisang keeps us from discarding their functions merely because they have no inherent substance.
The Two Extremes of Sweet Talk and Curt Rejection
I returned once more to the saju example. If you feed a visitor the sweet talk they want to hear and take their money, you are not even a monk. Yet we cannot say that the only correct answer is to snap, “Saju isn’t Buddhism,” and shut the door. Between those extremes lies the possibility of asking, “Why do you want your saju read?” You can discuss what makes the person anxious, what decision they face, and what their desire to know the future is grasping.
In this way, I answered Daous’s question about bisang-bibisang through Haeam Sunim’s question about saju. I asked the viewers whether they could feel the connection between the two. Bisang-bibisang is not the name of some faraway meditative attainment. It is the act of deciding what words to offer the person directly in front of us. We do not accept the mark called saju as a substantial reality, but we can see the other person’s mark as one of the conditions of the conversation. We seek a path that neither pushes the person away in order to protect the mark called Buddhism nor justifies superstition through the mark called expedient means.
Wisdom That Sees Situation and Mind Together Without a Fixed Answer
At about this point, the broadcast briefly cut out. I laughed and said, “It must be trying to end because it’s about time for us to finish.” An anonymous viewer said that they and their acquaintances often faced similar concerns even outside Buddhist matters, and I agreed. Within family, friendship, workplaces, and society, we keep choosing how much truth to speak, whether to respect or shatter someone’s belief, and whether to hold to a principle or maintain a relationship.
There is no fixed answer. Judging what is wise according to a situation and relationship is truly difficult. Knowing a lot does not solve it, and a quick mind does not automatically handle it well. We must think for a long time, observe the conditions in front of us, and above all reflect on our own emotions and expectations. Near the end of the broadcast I said that we should all live well. But each person has a different mark of what “living well” means. By grasping a mistaken mark of the good life, people sometimes make both themselves and others suffer instead.
Today I mixed Daous’s question about bisang-bibisang with Haeam Sunim’s saju question and tried to answer them within real relationships. I particularly asked Haeam Sunim’s understanding for drawing a personal experience so deeply into a public broadcast. I was not trying to judge or corner anyone in public. I hoped that a companion’s question might become the best possible condition for breaking his own delusion.
My broadcast is ultimately a liberation broadcast. It is not a broadcast in which I hand down answers for other people to memorize. I try to turn a question back toward one’s own mind, so that a person can see that a mark is not a mark and still use the marks needed in the world wisely. Whether to give a red pill, begin the relationship with a blue pill, remain silent, or ask a question depends on the person and the conditions at that moment. What makes that judgment possible is not authority or knowledge, but a mind capable of stopping, looking, and reflecting deeply. I ended the broadcast by wishing the viewers the attainment of Buddhahood.
This article was edited by AI solely from the supplied video captions and description. No external sources were used.